Most options traders are taught that Delta tells you the probability of an option expiring in the money. So selling a 10 Delta option sounds like a very safe trade. But is it? In this segment from Trading to Win, John Locke explains why options trading probability in theory is very different from your probability in the real market.
Click here or on the video below to get the details!
Subscribe: YouTube
Theoretical Probability Is Not Functional Probability
Delta gives you the theoretical probability of an option expiring out of the money. But there’s also a probability of touching the option, which is much, much higher. And most trades have a stop-out point well before the option is ever touched.
Put those together and, depending on how your trade is set up, your actual probability of the trade working out can be far lower than the number Delta suggests. On top of that, the theoretical number stays the same regardless of the market environment.
What Delta Ignores About Options Trading Probability
As John explains, theoretical probability ignores where the price is, how it got there and what’s in the way of the price. You could have a 10 Delta option with virtually no chance of even being touched, and at other times that same 10 Delta option in a situation where it has a very high probability of being exceeded.
Take a bull trade on the Russell when the market is horrendously overextended, volatility is low, price got there fast, and it’s coming into a range of resistance. That’s an extremely low-probability trade. Low volatility puts your 10 Delta option closer than normal to the asset price, so you can withstand a smaller pullback, right when the market is set up for a pullback.
“It’s not about your theoretical probability, it’s about your contextual probability.”
John Locke
The Question That Really Matters
If you’d like to win more often, John says to ask this: given the market conditions on entry, what are the most probable movement scenarios in my asset during the life of this trade? That question is the key to determining functional options trading probabilities.
Random Periods vs. Predictable Periods
John likes to say technical analysis is right about half the time on average. But it’s contextual, and that number changes a lot from situation to situation. The market goes through random periods and highly predictable periods.
In random periods, technical analysis gives you virtually no edge, or even a negative edge if you try to force an opinion. That’s when you want to stand aside. In highly predictable periods, movement is very likely to do a certain thing. That’s where your edge lives, and where you want to push it. Your job as a trader is to recognize which type of period you’re in.
Why Traders Force Opinions
Many traders try to force an opinion in a random period because they have a trade on, they’re worried about their P&L, and they feel they have to win. As John points out, you’re not as logical as you think. Your brain will make up a logical argument to act on strong emotions. It will delete, distort and even make up information to “logically satisfy” the emotion.
Key Takeaways
- Delta gives you theoretical probability, not your real probability of a trade working out.
- The probability of touching and your stop-out point change your odds.
- Theoretical probability ignores where price is, how it got there and what’s in the way.
- Ask what the most probable movement scenarios are during the life of your trade.
- Stand aside in random periods and push your edge in highly predictable periods.
Watch the extended video in our Explore More and Sustain membership on YouTube on this topic.
Or are you ready to learn options trading with up to 5 hours of live trader coaching every week? Explore the Locke In Your Success Trading Community membership. Basic membership is FREE!
Disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only. We are not broker-dealers or financial advisors and are not making specific trade recommendations. Trading involves substantial risk, and past or hypothetical results do not guarantee future performance.



Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.